Luke 24:1-12
Living Presence
James Sledge April
17, 2022
Early on a Sunday morning, several women
return from the empty tomb and tell the others what they had just experienced,
how they had found the tomb empty and encountered two men in dazzling clothes.
Presumably these were angels, and they had told the women that Jesus was risen.
When they tell the others, however, the women do not find the most receptive
audience for their account. Says the reading, But these words seemed to
them an idle tale, and they did not believe them.Easter Morning,
Cara B. Hochhalter
Over the years, many have commented on the role gender may have played in this. After all, it was a patriarchal society where women’s voices did not carry that much weight, and the women’s words perhaps seemed an idle tale because men didn’t trust women as reliable witnesses. I’ve no doubt commented on this dynamic in some of my past Easter sermons.
But it turns out that Luke’s gospel does not report some women bringing a report back to male disciples. Instead, it tells of female disciples who bring back a report to the eleven and to all the rest. And no doubt all the rest included more female disciples.
Now if these women are disciples, and if some of those hearing their report are also female disciples, then judging the report an idle tale isn’t about not believing female witnesses. Rather, it seemed an idle tale because it was too difficult to believe. Dead people stay dead. No one goes to a cemetery expecting to meet anyone once buried there, and most of us would think anyone who said they had needed to see a psychiatrist.