Matthew 14:22-33
Testing Faith: Stepping Out of the Boat
James Sledge August
9, 2020
Even
in an age of biblical illiteracy, a great many people have heard of Jesus
walking on the water. It’s a well-worn metaphor. The part about Peter walking
on the water may not be as well known, but I heard the story enough growing up
in the church that it’s familiar to me and, perhaps, to many of you.
If
you are familiar with the story, what are your thoughts on Peter? How does he
function in this story, as a heroic figure, an example to follow? Or is he a vivid
illustration of the disciples’ regular failure to “get it,” their struggles
with faith?
I
don’t know if I came to this on my own or if I picked it up along the way from
sermons and Sunday School, but I’ve long thought of Peter as a cautionary tale,
a failure, the one you don’t want to be, soaking wet with Jesus wagging a
finger at you. “You of little faith…”
I
mentioned in last week’s sermon how my father read Bible stories to us as children.
This helped me learn many of the major stories from the Bible, but it also
oversimplified them, making them a bit like comic books. And that view of
Scripture stuck with me well into adulthood.
I
thought of the Bible as mostly a collection of simple, even crude stories with
clear and obvious meanings. This thinking was encouraged by popular notions of
the Bible as straightforward reports of “what happened.” It never occurred to
me that much of the Bible was written by sophisticated theological thinkers who
told carefully nuanced stories, filled with symbolism and multiple layers of
meaning.
In
my simple, comic book view, our gospel reading is a plain old miracle story,
another fantastical account of the unbelievable stuff Jesus could do. The
disciples are there just to provide terrified, awe-filled witnesses, and Peter,
well Peter’s tendency to speak first and think later always got him into trouble.
And here he goes again.