Today's story in Exodus, where the Israelites make a golden calf and Moses shatters the two tablets written by God's own hand, might be considered a "primitive" story. God's behavior is very human-like, and Yahweh threatens to wipe out the Israelites in a fit of anger. Fortunately Moses begs for God to remember the promises to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. "And Yahweh changed his mind about the disaster that he planned to bring on his
people."
But if the story contains some "primitive" notions of God, it also speaks directly to issues that impact faith communities in our day, although people often seem to miss this. They read the story as an account of fickle Israelites turning from God the moment God isn't there for them. In the standard telling, the Israelites trade Yahweh, the living God, for a golden calf. But I think this misunderstands the events.
After Aaron has created the calf and an altar to go with it, he declares, "Tomorrow shall be a festival to Yahweh." To Yahweh. Not to some invented god, but to Yahweh. The Israelites seem less interested in replacing Yahweh than in making God more reliable and available. This unpictureable Yahweh is a bit too slippery. They want a god who is available on demand. They need manageable access to God. Moses has been their only source of access, and he's gone missing. They need something that can't run off on them.
It is the perennial religious problem. We want God on our terms, available on demand, amenable to our requests, sympathetic to our agendas. We aren't "primitive" enough to cast golden calves, but we have more "sophisticated" methods for creating a god who does as we wish. And so our idols are more sophisticated, but they are idols nonetheless.
What methods do you use to get God on your side, to make sure God agrees with you, to keep God in your camp? And more importantly, what methods do you have for letting God shatter your idols? How are we to open ourselves to God's transforming presence that breaks through our idolatries and recreates us more and more in the image of Jesus?
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Sermons and thoughts on faith on Scripture from my time at Old Presbyterian Meeting House and Falls Church Presbyterian Church, plus sermons and postings from "Pastor James," my blog while pastor at Boulevard Presbyterian in Columbus, OH.
Monday, April 30, 2012
Sunday, April 29, 2012
Sermon - Following Along Behind
John 10:11-18
Following Along Behind
James
Sledge April
29, 2012
When I was in
seminary, I had the opportunity to take a three week trip to the Middle East
and Greece. It was a remarkable
experience, and I got to see all sorts of wonderful historical, archeological,
and religious sites. There was much on
the trip that was memorable, but one of the more vivid memories for me was not
one of these sites but something I saw along the way.
I'm not sure which site we were headed
to or coming from. I think maybe it was
the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem.
Our group was on a charter bus, and we were driving along a winding road
through the undulating hills of the region.
As I looked out my window, I spotted
something moving across the rocky terrain, headed down into a valley. Focusing on it, I realized that it was a
young Palestinian boy. He looked to be
around twelve years old, and he was walking along a well-worn path. And right behind him, in a single fill line,
followed twelve or fifteen sheep. He was
not even looking back at them. He simply
walked along the path, and the sheep walked right along behind. It looked a little like a teacher leading a
group of elementary students to the cafeteria.
I've since learned that this is fairly
typical of Middle Eastern shepherding practices, both nowadays and in biblical
times. I suppose that my notions of
herding were shaped by cowboy scenes with huge numbers of cattle being driven. But with sheep, in biblical lands at least,
it is a more relational activity. The
sheep learn to trust the shepherd, and so they will follow where he or she
leads. I could not hear anything as I
gazed out the bus window that day, but I suppose that the young boy must have
called his little flock and then headed down that trail with them following
along behind.
"I am the good shepherd. I know my own and my own know me." This is one of a number of I AM sayings in the gospel of John.
Thursday, April 26, 2012
What Does God Do?
If I sit down beside a stranger on an airline, and if we decide to introduce ourselves to each other, invariably one of us will ask, "So what do you do?" It's a standard get-to-know-someone question. It's relatively safe and non-controversial. And it also a good question because what people "do" says a great deal about who they are. We acknowledge as much when we ask young children, "What do you want to be when you grow up?" Even though we may say "be" we aren't asking about their existential status. We expect them to answer with a vocation or occupation. "I'm going to be a firefighter."
We tend to draw a significant part of our self-identity from what we do: our work, our hobbies, our studies, our volunteer activities, etc. However, in my own perception of growing up Christian, that identity had more to do with what I believed than anything I did.
In today's reading from Exodus, God shows up to give the Israelites the "10 Commandments." This isn't the tablets that many associate with these commandments. This is simply God speaking directly to the people. God does not generally speak directly to people in the Bible, and so an introduction is necessary. "I am Yahweh your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery." Who are you and what do you do? "I'm Yahweh, and I free people from bondage."
There's been a great deal of talk in recent years about the "practices" that form individuals and communities into people of faith. In some congregations, what had been called "Christian Education" is starting to be referred to as "Christian Formation." The shift, in part, speaks of a move beyond what I know or believe, a move that also speaks of what I do.
Jesus certainly did plenty of teaching, but he also did lots of healing and feeding and such. And he told his followers lots of things the were to do. Jesus talked a great deal about the Kingdom drawing near, and this Kingdom was not a hope for heaven. It is a transformed world that operates by different rules, a place where things get done for the sake of the neighbor, the weak and oppressed, rather than self or for those with influence and power. It is a new sort of world where life has been completely reorganized around the practice of neighborliness.
So what do you do? I think Jesus is God's fullest answer to that question. And if we are going to slap the label "Christian" on ourselves or our society or our country, then surely our answer to "What do you do?" needs to look a bit like God's answer.
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
We tend to draw a significant part of our self-identity from what we do: our work, our hobbies, our studies, our volunteer activities, etc. However, in my own perception of growing up Christian, that identity had more to do with what I believed than anything I did.
In today's reading from Exodus, God shows up to give the Israelites the "10 Commandments." This isn't the tablets that many associate with these commandments. This is simply God speaking directly to the people. God does not generally speak directly to people in the Bible, and so an introduction is necessary. "I am Yahweh your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery." Who are you and what do you do? "I'm Yahweh, and I free people from bondage."
There's been a great deal of talk in recent years about the "practices" that form individuals and communities into people of faith. In some congregations, what had been called "Christian Education" is starting to be referred to as "Christian Formation." The shift, in part, speaks of a move beyond what I know or believe, a move that also speaks of what I do.
Jesus certainly did plenty of teaching, but he also did lots of healing and feeding and such. And he told his followers lots of things the were to do. Jesus talked a great deal about the Kingdom drawing near, and this Kingdom was not a hope for heaven. It is a transformed world that operates by different rules, a place where things get done for the sake of the neighbor, the weak and oppressed, rather than self or for those with influence and power. It is a new sort of world where life has been completely reorganized around the practice of neighborliness.
So what do you do? I think Jesus is God's fullest answer to that question. And if we are going to slap the label "Christian" on ourselves or our society or our country, then surely our answer to "What do you do?" needs to look a bit like God's answer.
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Wednesday, April 25, 2012
Surprised by God
In today's gospel, Jesus comes out to the Jordan to be baptized by John. John, who has been telling people to get ready, to change their ways in anticipation of the new thing that is coming, is caught off guard by the manner in which this new thing arrives. He does not want to baptize Jesus. It does not make sense to him.
Given how surprised John is by the situation, how at odds it is with what he expects, he comes around quite easily. Jesus says one sentence to John. "Then he consented." John sure seemed open to the unexpected, to being surprised by God.
In his devotion for today, Fr. Richard Rohr writes,
If "the truth comes from the edges," how do we who are heavily invested in the center hear its voice?
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Given how surprised John is by the situation, how at odds it is with what he expects, he comes around quite easily. Jesus says one sentence to John. "Then he consented." John sure seemed open to the unexpected, to being surprised by God.
In his devotion for today, Fr. Richard Rohr writes,
As I am learning the ropes in a new, larger congregation (Are pastors ever "called" to smaller congregations?), a church with more programs, activities, and resources, I am acutely aware of how difficult it can be to be surprised by God. Surely God is already located in all those things we've been doing all this time. Surely God would not act in ways that threaten any of those ways we're so invested in.The truth comes from the edges of society. Jesus’ reality is affirmed and announced on the margins, where people are ready to understand and to ask new questions. The establishment at the center is seldom ready for the truth because it's got too much to protect; it has bought into the system. As Walter Brueggeman says, “the home of hope is hurt.”
If "the truth comes from the edges," how do we who are heavily invested in the center hear its voice?
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Tuesday, April 24, 2012
Leadership, the Spirit, and Permission
A strange mix of voices has combined to speak to me this day. In today's staff meeting we did a lectio divina exercise where I was drawn to this phrase from today's Colossians reading, "worthy of the Lord." As I transition into my new role as pastor here, this seemed to be reminding me that my work is for God. The tasks of ministry must be in service to Christ's call to follow him.
At the very same time I found myself reflecting on a blog from Diana Butler Bass in light of an Exodus reading from earlier this week. In that passage, Jethro advises his son-in-law Moses to select elders to help him in his work guiding and leading the people of Israel. The conclusion of that blog, "Granting Permission: an Act of Trust" read,
There is no avoiding a congregation taking on some of the personality of its pastor, but it always bears remembering that it is Christ's Church, not mine. No trying to keep the wind of the Spirit boxed up in the pastor's study. Doors and windows open; let the Spirit blow through the congregation.
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
At the very same time I found myself reflecting on a blog from Diana Butler Bass in light of an Exodus reading from earlier this week. In that passage, Jethro advises his son-in-law Moses to select elders to help him in his work guiding and leading the people of Israel. The conclusion of that blog, "Granting Permission: an Act of Trust" read,
Permission-granting trust is a very biblical thing, and is the heart of a church awakened to being God’s presence in the world. In the Gospels, Jesus awakened his followers to God’s mission of compassion and spiritual transformation when he sent the Twelve into Galilee’s villages and towns. When Jesus sent the disciples on that first mission, he did not give them a list of rules. Instead, he instructed them in some practices, and gave the disciples “power and authority” to enact the good news themselves. He gave them permission to heal, teach, and preach. There were no rules and many risks. Jesus trusted his friends to do the work of God’s reign.As a pastor, someone with specialized training in theology, Bible, and worship, I often find it difficult to turn loose. Some of this may simply be my being a control freak, but some is a worry about things being done correctly. In many congregations the pastor may be the only person with any theological training, and those learnings need to be considered. But at the very same time, it cannot possibly be that the Spirit works only through the pastor. How much of my clinging to control is a failure to trust the work of the Spirit?
The Great Awakening for which we long begins with the sort of radical trust that grants permission go beyond the rules and to do the works of the Kingdom. We can fully expect that not everything we do will succeed, but we can be sure that we will have embarked on an adventure of faith into the world. And we will come to discover, as the disciples did, that being sent to the do the Spirit’s work is much more rewarding than staying at home hoping religious rules will save us.
There is no avoiding a congregation taking on some of the personality of its pastor, but it always bears remembering that it is Christ's Church, not mine. No trying to keep the wind of the Spirit boxed up in the pastor's study. Doors and windows open; let the Spirit blow through the congregation.
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Monday, April 23, 2012
O Lord, It's Hard To Be Humble
Humility is not much valued in our culture. We do appreciate it if a sports star or a CEO isn't too pretentious, but we know that they didn't get where they are simply by slogging away at their jobs. Rarely do people achieve such status without some degree of self promotion, without getting people to "Look at me!"
"Look at me" is modeled for us all the time. Watch the six o'clock news and you're likely to hear, "Only on News Channel 10..." The entire advertising industry is about "Look at me!" Voices all around us clamor constantly for our attention shouting, "Look at me, look at me!"
Churches get involved as well. I just set up a Facebook page and Facebook group for this congregation. Social media is an important way for churches to get their message out. But in the process we may simply add our voice to that cacophony screaming, "Look at me!"
Today's epistle reading says, "God opposes the proud, but gives grace to the humble." I wonder if I really believe that. I suppose I could just ignore this message. After all is comes from a seldom read letter, one that sometimes seems out of touch with Jesus' core message. ("Wives, submit to your husbands" is in here.) Problem is, "God opposes the proud, but gives grace to the humble," resonates perfectly with Jesus' message. It's not very different from Jesus' own, "So the last will be first, and the first will be last." And Jesus also says, "For all who exalt themselves will be humbled, but all who humble themselves will be exalted."
It seems to me that part of the difficulty embracing Jesus' way of thinking comes from the way we've pigeon-holed Christian faith into our way of doing things. We've failed to recognize what a radical idea Jesus' "kingdom of God" is. Or perhaps we have realized how radical it is and simply rejected it. After all, we're reasonably convinced that success, power, privilege, prestige, wealth, and so on are things that we achieve by hard work, that we earn in some way. But the Kingdom has all this socialist sounding talk of lifting up the lowly and dragging down the powerful. Consider Mary's song in Luke. "He has brought down the powerful from their thrones, and lifted up the lowly; he has filled the hungry with good things, and set the rich away empty." Sounds like "class warfare" to me.
The problem with grace is that you can't deserve it and you can't earn it. It pays no attention to status and does not respond to "Look at me!" Grace does not fit well into the rules that govern the world we live in, which is probably why Christian faith so often gets reduced to the issue of one's status after death. I'll get into heaven by grace. Everything else is up to me, except maybe God will bail me out of jam now and then if I'm a good little boy.
Today's gospel features John the Baptist saying, "Repent, for the kingdom of heaven has come near."(Employing typical Jewish deference, Matthew's gospel says "kingdom of heaven" rather than "of God.") Jesus quotes John exactly when he begins his ministry. Both the Baptist and Jesus insist that God's reign is coming, and we need to change our ways to fit its. Nothing about going to heaven here. It's about God's will being done on earth. It's about our world starting to mirror heaven.
But our world doesn't dare trust grace. We know that "God helps those who help themselves." (Not from the Bible, by the way.) And we don't really want our world to look like heaven. Then we wouldn't get to run it anymore.
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
"Look at me" is modeled for us all the time. Watch the six o'clock news and you're likely to hear, "Only on News Channel 10..." The entire advertising industry is about "Look at me!" Voices all around us clamor constantly for our attention shouting, "Look at me, look at me!"
Churches get involved as well. I just set up a Facebook page and Facebook group for this congregation. Social media is an important way for churches to get their message out. But in the process we may simply add our voice to that cacophony screaming, "Look at me!"
Today's epistle reading says, "God opposes the proud, but gives grace to the humble." I wonder if I really believe that. I suppose I could just ignore this message. After all is comes from a seldom read letter, one that sometimes seems out of touch with Jesus' core message. ("Wives, submit to your husbands" is in here.) Problem is, "God opposes the proud, but gives grace to the humble," resonates perfectly with Jesus' message. It's not very different from Jesus' own, "So the last will be first, and the first will be last." And Jesus also says, "For all who exalt themselves will be humbled, but all who humble themselves will be exalted."
It seems to me that part of the difficulty embracing Jesus' way of thinking comes from the way we've pigeon-holed Christian faith into our way of doing things. We've failed to recognize what a radical idea Jesus' "kingdom of God" is. Or perhaps we have realized how radical it is and simply rejected it. After all, we're reasonably convinced that success, power, privilege, prestige, wealth, and so on are things that we achieve by hard work, that we earn in some way. But the Kingdom has all this socialist sounding talk of lifting up the lowly and dragging down the powerful. Consider Mary's song in Luke. "He has brought down the powerful from their thrones, and lifted up the lowly; he has filled the hungry with good things, and set the rich away empty." Sounds like "class warfare" to me.
The problem with grace is that you can't deserve it and you can't earn it. It pays no attention to status and does not respond to "Look at me!" Grace does not fit well into the rules that govern the world we live in, which is probably why Christian faith so often gets reduced to the issue of one's status after death. I'll get into heaven by grace. Everything else is up to me, except maybe God will bail me out of jam now and then if I'm a good little boy.
Today's gospel features John the Baptist saying, "Repent, for the kingdom of heaven has come near."(Employing typical Jewish deference, Matthew's gospel says "kingdom of heaven" rather than "of God.") Jesus quotes John exactly when he begins his ministry. Both the Baptist and Jesus insist that God's reign is coming, and we need to change our ways to fit its. Nothing about going to heaven here. It's about God's will being done on earth. It's about our world starting to mirror heaven.
But our world doesn't dare trust grace. We know that "God helps those who help themselves." (Not from the Bible, by the way.) And we don't really want our world to look like heaven. Then we wouldn't get to run it anymore.
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Sunday, April 22, 2012
Sermon - Concrete Faith
Luke 24:36b-48; 1 John 3:1-7
Concrete Faith
April 22, 2012 James
Sledge
I
don’t know about here in Northern Virginia, but in the Carolinas where I grew
up, it was common for church congregations to hold “homecomings.” That’s the church version of a family
reunion. Invitations are sent out to old
members who have moved away and a big picnic is held after the service. The congregation in Raleigh, NC that I served
right out of seminary had not done homecomings.
But when we celebrated our 50th anniversary during my time
there, people enjoyed the festivities so much that they decided to hold annual
homecomings.
Homecomings
often feature former pastors coming back to preach, and so a few years after
leaving the Raleigh congregation I was invited back to be the quest preacher. I would like to think it an honor to receive
such an invitation. But in fact, all the
pastors who served before me except one were dead. And he was elderly and in poor health. And so I got the job mostly by default.
It’s
something of a peculiar thing to preach for a congregation you used to serve,
especially on a day when they are celebrating their heritage. There is no avoiding a certain amount of
reminiscing. You can’t help speaking
about the things that give a congregation its unique character, its personality. And when I began thinking of the things that
made that church in Raleigh the particular church that it was, I realized that most
of the things that came to my mind were tangible, concrete things. Some of those things were really concrete,
the buildings and structures. But they
were also the concrete things that had been done by members over the years, the
programs that were started, the special services that were held, the mission
activities that were planned and implemented, and so on.
It’s
the same for this congregation. When I first
learned that Falls Church was looking for a pastor, I went online and read a
document your PNC (pastor nominating committee) had written. It described some of the concrete things that
give this congregation its identity.
Thursday, April 19, 2012
No Time for Love
It's a perpetual problem for married couples. The intensity and passion they felt for each other early in the relationship gradually wanes. As time goes on, the routines of daily life often push the relationship further and further to the side. The demands of work, children, and more come to dominate, and it is not unusual for couples to live with one another without actually doing much loving. They may get along fine and be reasonably content, but things undertaken or done in order to love the other may become fewer and fewer.
"This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you." So says Jesus to his disciples shortly before his arrest and execution. In John's gospel, Jesus speaks of this a great deal. He clearly expects that loving one another will dominate the activity of his followers. And so it seems safe to presume it should dominate the activity of the Church. But there are so many other things that need to be taken care of, that have to be managed to keep congregations running.
I have to confess that after a little over a week as the new pastor at Falls Church Presbyterian, I'm feeling a bit overwhelmed by the tasks of running the church. Nothing alarming about this. It is to be expected when there is so much to learn: programs and activities, lots of names, office procedures and equipment, ways of doing things, and so on. But just as with couples, where the routines of life sometimes push the relationship to the side, the routines of church can do the same.
"This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you." Jesus gave us other commands, but I sometimes think that if we really were serious about loving, most of those would take care of themselves. So... how do I make sure that the busyness of church doesn't draw me away from the main business of loving?
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
"This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you." So says Jesus to his disciples shortly before his arrest and execution. In John's gospel, Jesus speaks of this a great deal. He clearly expects that loving one another will dominate the activity of his followers. And so it seems safe to presume it should dominate the activity of the Church. But there are so many other things that need to be taken care of, that have to be managed to keep congregations running.
I have to confess that after a little over a week as the new pastor at Falls Church Presbyterian, I'm feeling a bit overwhelmed by the tasks of running the church. Nothing alarming about this. It is to be expected when there is so much to learn: programs and activities, lots of names, office procedures and equipment, ways of doing things, and so on. But just as with couples, where the routines of life sometimes push the relationship to the side, the routines of church can do the same.
"This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you." Jesus gave us other commands, but I sometimes think that if we really were serious about loving, most of those would take care of themselves. So... how do I make sure that the busyness of church doesn't draw me away from the main business of loving?
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Wednesday, April 18, 2012
A Little Pruning
I cannot read today's gospel passage without thinking of my grandfather. That's because some years ago a preached a sermon from this text that related a story about my grandfather and grapevines. Until I left for seminary at age 35, I lived quite close to my grandfather. After he suffered a stroke that left him mostly blind, I began growing my own garden in the huge plot he had on his 6 or 7 acre property. And I would often take my older daughter with me when I went to work in the garden.
On one visit, we somehow began talking about all the grapevines that used to be on the property, and how I remembered my grandmother making muscadine and scuppernog jelly. Most of the vines had been taken by a road widening, but there was one small grapevine near the house. However it had not had grapes on it in years. When I mentioned this my grandfather said that was because no one had been pruning it.
And thus began a project to produce grapes and make jelly again. As Spring arrived my grandfather directed me in pruning the old grapevines. He could not see well, but he could see well enough to encourage me to prune more and more. I thought I was being pretty drastic in my whacking off huge sections, but he insisted more had to go. By the time we were done, I had butchered the poor thing thoroughly. I might even have wondered if I had damaged it.
Turns out my grandfather knew something about grapevines. It wasn't long before new vines were traveling down the wires he had long ago strung between what looked like clothesline poles. Then tiny bunches of grapes began to appear which eventually loaded the vines down with a bumper crop. Later my grandmother helped me and four-year-old Kendrick make jelly with some of them.
It seems somewhat strange to me that those grapevines had stopped producing fruit because no one had pruned them. They appeared healthy and were covered in new leaves and growth each year. But no grapes.
Jesus speaks of us as branches on the vine that need pruning. Obviously Jesus knew something about grapevines because he speaks of pruning the branches that bear fruit so they will bear more. And it makes me wonder about what needs pruning with me. What needs to be pared back so that new and productive growth can emerge?
And what about our congregations? Congregations often can't bear to let go of anything no matter how long it's been since it was productive. But if we let Jesus direct the pruning efforts, I wonder where would he say to us, "No, you need to cut off a good bit more."
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
On one visit, we somehow began talking about all the grapevines that used to be on the property, and how I remembered my grandmother making muscadine and scuppernog jelly. Most of the vines had been taken by a road widening, but there was one small grapevine near the house. However it had not had grapes on it in years. When I mentioned this my grandfather said that was because no one had been pruning it.
And thus began a project to produce grapes and make jelly again. As Spring arrived my grandfather directed me in pruning the old grapevines. He could not see well, but he could see well enough to encourage me to prune more and more. I thought I was being pretty drastic in my whacking off huge sections, but he insisted more had to go. By the time we were done, I had butchered the poor thing thoroughly. I might even have wondered if I had damaged it.
Turns out my grandfather knew something about grapevines. It wasn't long before new vines were traveling down the wires he had long ago strung between what looked like clothesline poles. Then tiny bunches of grapes began to appear which eventually loaded the vines down with a bumper crop. Later my grandmother helped me and four-year-old Kendrick make jelly with some of them.
It seems somewhat strange to me that those grapevines had stopped producing fruit because no one had pruned them. They appeared healthy and were covered in new leaves and growth each year. But no grapes.
Jesus speaks of us as branches on the vine that need pruning. Obviously Jesus knew something about grapevines because he speaks of pruning the branches that bear fruit so they will bear more. And it makes me wonder about what needs pruning with me. What needs to be pared back so that new and productive growth can emerge?
And what about our congregations? Congregations often can't bear to let go of anything no matter how long it's been since it was productive. But if we let Jesus direct the pruning efforts, I wonder where would he say to us, "No, you need to cut off a good bit more."
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Monday, April 16, 2012
Exclusive Claims
In today's gospel, Jesus utters one of those line-in-the-sand phrases. "No one comes to the Father except through me." It is a line sometimes drawn as a weapon in religious debates. And those who wield it as such often assume that Jesus is making universal, absolute claims about can be saved, know God, etc.
It sure would be nice if we could ask the author of John's gospel his thoughts on what Jesus means, but of course we cannot. But that doesn't mean we have no interpretive window where we might look for insights. For example, it is typical for people in our day to think of Scripture as a way of communicating Christian faith to non-believers, and there are any number of organizations committed to getting Bibles to people as an evangelical strategy. But the first readers of John's gospel would not of have thought this way at all.
None of the New Testament was written for the general public. These were in-house documents, used by insiders only. By itself, this raises the question of whether Jesus' statement about "No one" refers to no one in all creation or to no one of you, the community of faith.
I also wonder if it makes any difference that Jesus says "the Father" rather than God. Clearly the people of John's community had encountered God's love through Jesus in way that transformed their understanding of God. This new thing was totally dependent on Jesus, but that is not the same thing as saying, "All other religious experience is invalid."
Another question is the status of John's community as tiny, endangered minority compared to the powerful and often privileged situation of the Church in the Western World. How well do the bold, even defiant claims of one small community translate into universal truths? And what about the fact that John's Jewish community is locked in a struggle with fellow Jews who have not embraced Jesus? Do these intrafaith debates translate into larger interfaith dialogues?
I am not meaning to suggest a religious relativism that says all experiences of God are equally valid. Like John's community, I too know God through Jesus, and I experience God in my life as Jesus "abides" in me via the Spirit. I have no other way to know the God that I do, and I feel quite free to reject any religious claim that presents a god who is contrary to this loving God I know in Christ. But does that mean that having the correct Christological labels is the key?
There's an oft quoted statement from Gandhi that goes, "I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ." I can't help but think this comment might encourage Christians to read Jesus' words from today's gospel more as a tool for internal critique than for external judgments. If we Christians don't look like Christ, it seems that we are the ones who don't know the way to the Father.
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
It sure would be nice if we could ask the author of John's gospel his thoughts on what Jesus means, but of course we cannot. But that doesn't mean we have no interpretive window where we might look for insights. For example, it is typical for people in our day to think of Scripture as a way of communicating Christian faith to non-believers, and there are any number of organizations committed to getting Bibles to people as an evangelical strategy. But the first readers of John's gospel would not of have thought this way at all.
None of the New Testament was written for the general public. These were in-house documents, used by insiders only. By itself, this raises the question of whether Jesus' statement about "No one" refers to no one in all creation or to no one of you, the community of faith.
I also wonder if it makes any difference that Jesus says "the Father" rather than God. Clearly the people of John's community had encountered God's love through Jesus in way that transformed their understanding of God. This new thing was totally dependent on Jesus, but that is not the same thing as saying, "All other religious experience is invalid."
Another question is the status of John's community as tiny, endangered minority compared to the powerful and often privileged situation of the Church in the Western World. How well do the bold, even defiant claims of one small community translate into universal truths? And what about the fact that John's Jewish community is locked in a struggle with fellow Jews who have not embraced Jesus? Do these intrafaith debates translate into larger interfaith dialogues?
I am not meaning to suggest a religious relativism that says all experiences of God are equally valid. Like John's community, I too know God through Jesus, and I experience God in my life as Jesus "abides" in me via the Spirit. I have no other way to know the God that I do, and I feel quite free to reject any religious claim that presents a god who is contrary to this loving God I know in Christ. But does that mean that having the correct Christological labels is the key?
There's an oft quoted statement from Gandhi that goes, "I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ." I can't help but think this comment might encourage Christians to read Jesus' words from today's gospel more as a tool for internal critique than for external judgments. If we Christians don't look like Christ, it seems that we are the ones who don't know the way to the Father.
Click to learn more about the Daily Lectionary.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)