Matthew 22:34-46
Passionate, Fearless Love
James Sledge October
29, 2-17
A
version of today’s gospel reading appears in Matthew, Mark, and Luke, which all
follow the same basic timeline. But only Matthew has the question about the
greatest commandment as part of Jesus’ final confrontation with his opponents.
In Matthew, this is the last effort to catch Jesus in some mistake, to outwit
him in some way.
Perhaps Matthew wants to highlight two issues
for his Jewish congregation before he
gets to Jesus’ final teachings and then his arrest and crucifixion. Perhaps he
wants to highlight Jesus as the faithful and reliable interpreter of the Law
and the Prophets, the chosen successor to Moses, and who Jesus is as Messiah,
the anointed one of God.
Using
a quote from the Psalms to talk about Jesus as Messiah probably doesn’t grab us
like it might have people in Jesus’ day. The way Jesus uses scripture to prove
his point was typical of rabbis in his day, but it doesn’t sound all that
convincing to me, or perhaps to you.
But
Jesus’ words on the greatest commandment have resonated down through the
centuries. People with little connection to church may well be familiar with,
“Love God with heart, soul, and mind. And love your neighbor as yourself.”
Jesus
of course quotes from what we call the Old Testament. After all, he’s been
asked which commandment from there is number one. Jesus names his choice, calling it “the greatest and first
commandment,” but he’s unwilling to stop with just one, adding a second
that is “like it.” Taken together, says Jesus, obeying these two commandments
will keep you in line on pretty much all the rest.
In
my experience, many people tend to move quickly past the greatest and first
commandment, turning the focus on loving neighbor. That happens in the
gospel of Luke, where the person questioning Jesus has an immediate follow-up. “And
who is my neighbor?” To which Jesus responds with the parable of the
Good Samaritan.
But
we’re in Matthew, not Luke, and there is no follow-up to Jesus’ statement on the
greatest commandment. There are simply the two commandments, and one of them is
the
greatest and first commandment. It is also the longer commandment, with
more elaborate language. “You shall love the Lord your God with all
your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind.” And so I
wonder if we wouldn’t do well not to be in a rush to get to the one about
loving neighbor. I wonder if we wouldn’t do well to linger here a bit and
consider what it means to love God with all your heart and all your soul and
all your mind.